Login
Not a CAA member?
Read about the benefits.
August 10, 2001
Anne D. Hedeman Of Counselors and Kings: The Three Versions of Pierre Salmon’s Dialogues Champaign: University of Illinois Press, 2001. 123 pp.; 8 color ills.; 39 b/w ills. Cloth $49.95 (0252026144)
Thumbnail

 
CrossRef DOI: 10.3202/caa.reviews.2001.15

Sign In or become a member to see the full review

Anne D. Hedeman’s Of Counselors and Kings offers a comprehensive investigation of the Dialogues of Pierre Salmon. Salmon was an advisor to the ill-starred French king Charles VI (r. 1380-1422), whose debilitating mental illness contributed to a series of profound crises during his reign. The manuscripts consist of a set of questions purportedly posed by the king to Salmon—first concerning political issues and then theological matters—followed by a collection of transcribed letters relating to Salmon’s attempts to discover a remedy for the king’s illness. A second, slightly later version of the text also includes a lengthy treatise on virtues and vices. Hedeman’s concise study will undoubtedly prompt a reappraisal of the Dialogues, which scholars previously investigated using a flawed nineteenth-century edition. By directly examining the original manuscripts, Hedeman provides a subtle analysis of the shifting meanings that the text conveyed to its earliest audiences. On its own, this would be enough to mark her work as a major addition to scholarship on the Dialogues. But Of Counselors and Kings accomplishes much more. It significantly expands our understanding of late-medieval court patronage. An earlier generation of art historians tended to present kings and dukes as the driving forces behind commissions (e.g....